To Hug or Not to Hug? The Controversy Surrounding Teacher and Student Hugs: Exploring the Need and Boundaries

Teacher and Student Hugs: Being a teacher automatically makes you a guardian to your students, and often, they may come to you for support emotionally, physically, or in other forms and some reactions may result in hugs, maybe after they lose someone, or succeded in a hard challenge etc.

I have been a teacher for decades and know there are specific ways teachers can express themselves to their students.

If you are a grade or high school teacher, you’d know that students face many challenges and sometimes only need a little emotional support.

From their parents having a constant fight to being bullied outside the school, it can take the student into their shell and affect their academics or mental health.

Source: Google

As a teacher who often plays the role of a gaurdian, it is up to you as the teacher to find a way to get them talking and provide a solution for them. One of our jobs as teachers is to connect with your students emotionally. 

Happy and sad moments have made me show compassion to my students in various forms, including hugs. Wrapping them in your arms and telling them everything will be alright might be all they need.

ut as a teacher, there should be limits to these things. Learning to balance these emotions with your job is necessary as a teacher.

Should Teachers Hug Their Students?

The debate about teachers showing emotions to their students through hugs has brought different perspectives from different people.

It is alright for teachers to show emotions to their students, but still a bit skeptical if it should come through hugs, especially if your students have come of age. If you want to connect with your students through hugs, then there are certain things you should consider.

Source: Google

In all my years as a teacher, I have come to understand that being emotional with your students isn’t a bad idea, but how you show it can cause concern.

If you are a teacher, it is okay to show your emotions through hugs if your students are in elementary school. It is okay to wrap them in your arms like you’d hold your child, and of course, when they are in school, you automatically become their guardian.

But hugging your students may seem inappropriate and unprofessional if you are a teacher whose students are in middle school or high school. It could arouse suspicion from the students and, as the case may sometimes be, the management. 

If you feel hugging your students is right, you should consider the age factor first to avoid misinterpretation from the students and other staff members. If you must go on hugging your students, you must first consider the age grade of the students you are handling.

Another thing you should never forget is that your work is professional; even if you want to show emotions, you should be professional about it. Being professional about your relationship with your students creates a conducive learning environment. I have always supported my students in various ways. 

I remember when one of my students- name withheld- had a crisis in her family. Her parents were about to get a divorce, and she was in her senior year in high school, with the exams a few weeks away.

I met her crying in one of the classrooms after school, and she told me everything. I promised myself that I would give her all the support and care she needed, and with the help of my husband, we both made sure that she was okay.

In all of these, there were times my student needed hugs and pacts, which of course, I rendered her, but I never let emotions make me forget that I was her teacher and not her mother.

I constantly reminded her that I was her teacher and would do my best to get her out of that situation, leading me to talk to her parents.

After seeing her go through that phase, everything returned to normal, and I became that strict but playful teacher who didn’t mix professionalism with compassion. As a teacher, you should always be professional, even when you want to be compassionate.

If there should be any form of physical touch, including hugs, then the teacher should seek the student’s consent before taking any action.

Respecting personal boundaries is essential as a teacher because it brings about respect and comfort. It is crucial to keep these personal boundaries between you and your students. 

During my first time as a teacher in my first school, I was handed the school’s guidelines, and on the list was how being intimate with the student or making physical contact unnecessarily was inappropriate, and there was a penalty if found guilty.

In all three schools where I’ve been a teacher, the management helped draw the line in the Teacher-Student relationship as it was always deemed inappropriate and should stay professional.

If you ever want to show compassion to your students through physical touch, then you must also consider the school’s policy.

You must draw the line and keep it professional if they find physical contact between teachers and students inappropriate, which most schools do.

Can Teachers Hug Their Students From Behind?

Source: wIKIPEDIA

No. I’m going to be blunt about this. Teachers should not hug their students from behind except if the teacher is the student’s parent; otherwise, it is inappropriate to hug your student from behind.

Hugging someone from behind is often a gesture that shows a close bond or romantic interest between two people, and you wouldn’t want your students seeing you that way.

However, I’m also trying to see it from a different context. For example, hugging a female student from behind could be questioned if the teacher is male – society rules.

Also, a female student hugging a female teacher from behind could imply a close bond or trust between them. Either way, my main point is a male teacher hugging a female student from behind should be questioned but in the other case, it could be tagged as the female student feeling protected by the female teacher.

This is a tricky area sincerely and I’ll suggest both male and female teachers shouldn’t hug students from behind to avoid unfroseen issues. 

What Ways Can Teachers Show Their Students That They Care?

My favorite way to show my students I care is through encouragement and motivation. I always want to push my students forward and uplift their spirits, irrespective of the situation they find themselves in.

I improve my students’ mentality and emotional state by providing positive reinforcement and constructive guidance to help them grow and get through the emotional phase they face.

Showing care can come in hugs and patting of the backs and shoulders, but the hugs should always be minimal. Be compassionate with your students by letting them know they can survive the situation they are going through and may even emerge stronger from it. A little hug and pacts can help too.

I have mastered the art of being a good listener to my students whenever they have an emotional breakdown. I give them my full attention and listen to everything they say so I can render my candid advice or encouragement to strengthen them through the tough times they may be facing.

Students love it when they know they are being listened to with full attentiveness, I mean, we all do or don’t you? 

I remember a Junior High Student struggling in school and I opted to bond with her beyond school. I had to familiarize with her family and made sure I connected with her for her to be open to me about what’s going on with her.

I got to know her and what was going on with her. She was addicted to drugs and was looking for ways to quit it. I had a personal connection with her, and I vowed to help pull her out of the addiction, and this happened without me, forgetting that I was still her teacher. 

In all of these, you should understand that as a teacher, it is inevitable to show compassion to your students, and frequently you might be overwhelmed by emotions and make physical contact with them, which isn’t wrong. But be minimal about it and always remember to be professional.

How Can Teachers Balance Professionalism and Showing Care To Their Students?

Source: iStock

Professionalism is always the target of every teacher; it can be challenging to achieve it with compassion. There is every tendency that teachers will always be affectionate towards their students.

When their students are going through tough times, some teachers may forget professionalism and dive in fully with compassion. But putting professionalism and compassion on an equal scale is always possible. 

One tactic I use is building positive and inspiring relationships with my students. I get to know them beyond the school environment by getting to know them individually.

I always tell them I am interested in their lives and daily activities. I give them whenever they want to talk to me. Knowing them individually and remembering that you’re their teacher helps create an emotional bond between both parties.

It worked with my female student, and it has worked with others too. Building a positive relationship filled with respect helps balance professionalism and compassion between teachers and students.

Another thing I always do in any new class I’m teaching is to define the type of teacher I am and how I expect my students to act.

I let them in on my guidelines and expectations as their teacher. Even in times of showing compassion and hugs when they are going through patchy times, there should always be a boundary in the relationship between you and your students.

No matter the type of behavior they want to portray, your standards and guidelines will help keep them in check even when they receive hugs from you.

When I am having a conversation with my students, or I am communicating with them, I always maintain every level of professionalism in my words.

I always avoid sharing personal information with them so that it won’t be used against me in the long run. I always keep boundaries between my students, bringing professionalism to my job. Always stay professional, no matter your relationship with your students.

Conclusion

Hugging your students should not be your first way of showing care. While some students might take it as you reaching out because you naturally and genuinely care about them, others may take it the wrong way, and actions that will bring side talks from students are one thing I always advise teachers to avoid. Sometimes you can do a teacher and students hangout- note that I said teacher and students, not just one student. Also, always showing care to a particular student could be tagged as inappropriate, so you should avoid this too.